Mini-roundabouts: A great alternative for stop signs

By Justin Campbell

Mini-roundabouts -  increase traffic flow and improve safety

Mini-roundabouts are not as small as they sound, but they still are not on the radar for many cities.

Literally just miniature versions of full-size roundabouts – the only difference being a smaller island in the middle that larger vehicles can drive over – they provide many of the same benefits, including increased traffic flow and improved safety.

So why aren’t they on the radar? Roundabouts in general are still controversial due to:

  • Relatively low numbers of installed roundabouts
  • Uncertainty by City officials that a roundabout will solve their traffic issues at an intersection
  • Misperceptions by drivers that they are hard to navigate
Mini-roundabouts, while similar, require a different thought process when designing. Full-size roundabouts are designed first with large truck traffic in mind; mini-roundabouts are designed to accommodate the other 95% of vehicles first.

Several reasons make mini-roundabouts a great alternative for cities to consider when redesigning an intersection:

  • They are usually the lowest-cost option, both in construction and in maintenance.
  • They increase safety by slowing traffic, while at the same time keeping traffic flowing so you eliminate the congestion of two- and four-way stops.
  • Their compact size offers cities the flexibility of placing them within existing intersection spaces.
  • Construction is usually of short duration, around two weeks, and the intersection can remain open to traffic.
  • There are traffic safety and environmental programs available that can provide funding for building mini-roundabouts

Where do they work?

Where do mini-roundabouts work?Mini-roundabouts work great in residential neighborhoods where there is less large truck traffic, less than 15,000 vehicles entering daily, and speeds less than 35 mph. They fit within the existing curblines, so there’s no sidewalk interference or need for right-of-way purchases.

Intersections that have high delays, but do not meet traffic signal warrants, would also benefit from a mini-roundabout’s ability to increase capacity and eliminate the traffic backup that happens with stop signs.

Paving the way

The City of Coralville, Iowa is progressive in roundabouts and was the first in Iowa to build a mini-roundabout, completing construction in 2015. Marion will be the second city in Iowa, with design work complete and construction to be done this year.

Coralville selected the mini-roundabout in place of signalizing the intersection of 12th Avenue and Holiday Road. Previously there was a four-way stop, but traffic was backing up and the City needed to reduce congestion at the intersection. There wasn’t enough space for a full-size roundabout.

In researching Coralville’s options, a mini-roundabout was a great way to increase traffic flow while keeping the intersection safe for pedestrians. The University of Iowa’s Cambus drivers have had no trouble navigating the mini-roundabout with the ability to drive over the island curb.

The City of Marion, Iowa, had several safety concerns at the intersection of 29th Avenue and 35th Street. A two-way stop currently, vehicles are moving too fast for pedestrians to safely cross the street. Marion chose to install a mini-roundabout at the intersection this summer, since roundabouts in general are a great way to slow traffic while at the same time keep it moving, and the compact mini-roundabout was the right size for the residential neighborhood.

When considering options for an intersection, identify the current problems and see if a mini-roundabout is the solution that works. Just because it’s a new idea in Iowa, don’t let mini-roundabouts disappear from your radar.

Justin Campbell, PE   As a transportation engineer, problem solving in a collaborative- and team-based environment is the key to my clients’ success. Positivity and optimism allow me to see things through the lens of possibilities and I enjoy sharing this type of energy with my clients and colleagues.

Justin Campbell, PE
800.798.0227
jcampbell@shive-hattery.com

<< Back to Blog Listing


Print Print